Best iced tea maker machine

What is a better way to start your day than having an iced tea which gives your brain an instant boast of freshness? These machines will not only consistently produce better-tasting iced teas than you can hope to make by pouring cups of hot tea over ice, but will also end up saving you a great deal of money in the long run if you previously purchase ready-made iced teas. They will also help you to produce the healthiest and best-tasting teas, as most such units can use fresh loose tea leaves and extract the maximum possible nutrients and flavor. After more than 4 weeks of research and testing multiple iced tea makers we have concluded that:

‘’We believe Nostalgia CI3BK Café Ice 3-Quart Iced Coffee & Tea Brewing System is the best iced tea maker machine’’

Nostalgia CI3BK Café Ice 3-Quart Iced Coffee & Tea Brewing System  

This is our first choice and the best ice tea maker. This sleek black color, retro-look unit, though sub-$40 – looks great on countertops, even next to much more expensive stand mixer. 

Why it is the best iced tea maker machine?

The pitcher is extremely light but it is glass so it won’t be absorbing any odors and will be easy to clean if you forget it has tea and it happens to mold. The glass pitcher has an accurate pour (not leaking down the pitcher’s base) all the way to the end of the pour. Brews a full pitcher quickly. The black with chrome accent styling looks good on the counter compared to the ugly white plastic kinds. Can adjust the tea and brew strength.


  • Easy, affordable and convenient to use
  • Pitcher is glass  
  • It doesn’t leak all over the floor
  • Easy to clean Cons
  • Coffee may come out weak and watery. Filter never drains completely.
  • Glass pitcher and thin handle a bit scary
  • Plastic adjustable lid does not fit – it falls out when you pour from the pitcher

Why Better than Our Second choice

It functions better than the Mr. Coffee 3-QT model which always leaked after a few uses making it better than that.

Problem You May Face:

Though it has a much more elegant design and look BUT it takes up half the counter space (while not sacrificing much capacity).

Mr. Coffee Iced Tea Maker 

A stylish and easy-to-use automatic iced tea maker from Mr. Coffee will find its place in any kitchen. Delivered with a number of additional recipes, in mere minutes, it will make a full pitcher of fruit iced tea lemonade or any other brew to your liking to enjoy with your family and friends. This is the second best iced tea maker because of its less capacity and plastic pitcher but it is still good.

Why use this?

  • Use tea bags or loose tea leaves to brew great-tasting iced tea
  • Makes iced tea easily with convenient automatic shutoff
  • Pitcher has sturdy handle for steady pouring
  • Removable brew basket for easy cleaning On/off indicator light
  • Mr. Coffee Iced Tea Maker allowed us to leave the tea stewing as short or long as we wanted.


  • This Ice tea maker is just perfect. Makes great tea in no time with little clean up.
  • Easier more consistent brewing
  • You simply put in your water, put in tea and appropriate amount of ice, plug in and press button.
  • For storage, the pitcher fits over top the unit.


You may face some issues

  • You can’t see the water level when you fill it. It is also clumsy & leaks while making.
  • Too big to store.
  • The water reservoir is small.
  • The top of this pitcher (the blue part) does not have a manual lever on the side of the basket to allow the tea to “steep”. This basket just allows the water to drain through the basket into the pitcher and the tea is very weak when finished brewing.
  • The 3-quart pitcher may crack at the spout from the heat of the brewed tea.

Mr. Coffee 3-Quart Fresh Tea Iced Tea Maker

Why this?  

Thirsting for a better iced tea maker? With the ability to make 2 quarts of brewed iced tea, this machine is a great choice for iced tea lovers. And the removable brew basket means you’ll spend less time on cleanup, leaving more time to enjoy your delicious iced tea. The pitcher is designed with ice level markings for precise measuring, and a non drip spout for hassle-free pouring. Plus, it is dishwasher safe, which makes cleanup a breeze.


  • Easy to use  
  • The pitcher is dishwasher save
  • Recipe book included
  • It auto-shuts off when it’s done.
  • Takes up a lot of fridge space
  • If you don’t want to make ice, or don’t have a lot of ice on hand — play around with the water levels and you will find the right dilute amount that works instead of ice.


  • The markings on the container could be designed better and overall construction seems a bit flimsy
  • Requires several brewing actions & really does not make 3 quarts.
  • The lids do not fit properly and the pitcher does not fill to the 3qt line. Worked fine at first but had occasional leaking. Which makes it the third best iced tea maker machine.


A detailed best iced tea maker review has been done to make it easier for you to decide which one you should buy among the three best iced tea maker machines along with the pros and cons.

If you want to buy iced tea maker that is highly efficient and compatible in making the best iced tea Nostalgia iced tea maker is the best iced tea maker which is highly affordable and with large capacity. But if you’re looking for a non-cracking iced tea maker buy Mr. Coffee maker. Mr. Coffee 3-quart iced tea maker is also worth looking for.